AI Tool Evaluation Criteria
How to assess AI tools before you commit budget.
Data Security & GDPR
Where is your data stored? Who can access it? Does the vendor encrypt in transit and at rest? What GDPR commitments do they make? Verify data processing agreements and compliance certifications before signing.
Integration Capability
Does the tool connect to your existing systems? APIs available? Native integrations with your CRM, accounting software, or HR systems? Poor integration kills adoption. Test real data flows before purchase.
Total Cost of Ownership
What is the true cost over three years? Include licence fees, implementation, training, maintenance, and future upgrades. Compare per-user, per-feature, and subscription pricing models. Do not assume costs stay flat.
Vendor Stability
Is the vendor profitable? What is their funding status? How long have they been operating? What is their customer retention rate? Talk to current customers about reliability and roadmap confidence.
Scalability
Does the tool scale with your growth? Can it handle larger data volumes, more users, or increased complexity? What are the performance limits? Plan for your needs in three years, not today.
User Experience
Is the interface intuitive? Do your team members actually want to use it? Bad UX kills adoption regardless of functionality. Request extended trials and involve end-users in your evaluation.
Support & Training
What support do you get? Documentation quality? Response times? Do they offer onboarding and training? A cheap tool with no support becomes expensive when problems arise.
Exit Strategy
What happens if you leave? Can you export your data in standard formats? How long does migration take? Check their data portability terms and avoid vendor lock-in on critical systems.
Why Most AI Tool Purchases Fail
Organisations spend heavily on AI tools and see disappointing adoption. The root cause: poor evaluation. Many purchases skip security checks, miss integration problems, or ignore total cost of ownership. Users are not trained. Exit costs trap you in bad relationships.
Use these eight criteria to make confident procurement decisions. Involve your team. Test before committing. Get governance approval. Build exit strategies into contracts. Strong evaluation prevents costly mistakes.
Need Vendor Evaluation Support?
Our framework works for initial screening. Complex procurement decisions need vendor assessment and negotiation support.
Get Evaluation Support